12-Jul to 26-Jul
Young players from the academy storming into the senior squad are positives signs for McDowell Mohun Bagan.
Verdict
|
tania
Academy players coming through is proof that the club's efforts and investments are headed in the right path. Continuing with these efforts will help in building a structured plan to ensure development of talented youngsters for both club and country. |
|
"This is always a good sign. Players coming through the academy ensures that there is a supply chain in place for the senior squad."
|
93%
|
|
7%
|
"As good as this sounds, the numbers have not been very significant and steady. We are still dependent on player signings to fill voids in the squad."
|
|
Most European powerhouses thrive on the players their academies churn out. The fact that we are emulating similar success will help the club in the long run and also produce quality players for the national squad.
Players from the academy are not yet playing leading roles in the team. They should be given exposure in smaller tournaments to see if they have the mettle to play for the club at the top flight.
FOR
18 Opinions
& 25 Votes
Rahul Chakraborty says:
I think the academies should go for a selection of 9 to 12 of the age group.. It would make the choices more valuable
21 Jul 2012
jit hazra says:
ITS OBVIOUSLY A POSITIVE N GOOD SIGN FOR MOHUNBAGAN.IN A BROADER PERSPECTIVE, FOR INDIA TOO.THEY WILL STRENGTHEN OUR TEAM N THESE YOUNG BLOODS WILL ADD MORE SPEED,ENERGY TO D TEAM.THEIR POTNTIALS WILL DEFENITELY B BENIFITIAL FOR THE SINIOR TEAM.THEY MAY FURNISH D TEAM WITH GREAT QUALITIES.AS TALENTS NEED CHANCES,THEY SHOULD BE WELCOMED N GIVEN ENOUGH CHANCES AND A STRONG RESERVE BNCH FORMED BY THESE SKILFUL BOYS CAN HLP MOHUNBAGAN TO RULE INDIAN FOOTBALL ONCE AGAIN.
21 Jul 2012
Soumik Bose says:
Well most of the world's top clubs have done so good because of their Academy..from Barcelona to Liverpool, a good academy is important for a club to get the new players into the main stream and its like a responsibility for a club like ours!
19 Jul 2012
Soumik Chakraborty says:
yeah its realy gd bt if they r traind and coachd wl they can be heroes of india
17 Jul 2012
Subhranshu Ghosh says:
Agree.....But still our academy is not as good as even smaller European clubs. way to go....
17 Jul 2012
Prasanta Batabyal says:
I personally think that it is very positive side for us having so many young footballer in our side. These players if well guided by the coach
17 Jul 2012
Abhilash Roy says:
I agree with the motion. I think its good to see young talent always come up. Its good on their part as they get the exposure to show their talent and get to learn a lot from the seniors and vice versa. After all its called TEAM MOHUN BAGAN and discrimination should not be made on the basis of senoirs and juniors. Because talent is not measured in terms of senoirs and juniors. Its something that an individual has to harness over a period of time.
16 Jul 2012
Abhinandan Ghosh says:
It is good that at least one club from Bengal is doing some thing so that young players can get the opportunity to get well training from the very early stage of life,and they reach there goal of playing for the national club of India
16 Jul 2012
Subhajit Mandal says:
Juvenile players are seriously in the other season......so its big time to welcome them in the squad. Their energy are high.....and can give the team a fresh start.
14 Jul 2012
sujoy kumar das says:
YES YES YES
14 Jul 2012
sujoy kumar das says:
Yes
14 Jul 2012
mansour muhiz says:
i am also young and i have got a very good skill.i want to become a football player and i hope the club helps me.
14 Jul 2012
chandan mondal says:
this is always good.this is the supply line of a new talent. no one can say in this young talent we find another vasum or like other player.
13 Jul 2012
arnab kundu says:
Supply Chain Management is the Best and Easiest key of sucess.
13 Jul 2012
avick tribedi says:
altho the number os players coming in is less. still we can say that v hav a good academy to support our senior team... all professional clubs depend on big transfers.. but keeping a strong scout squad is always useful...
13 Jul 2012
sudipta chakraborty says:
Its a good sine because manish has manage to find himself in the senior squad through performance. It will create a healthy completion among the teammate..
13 Jul 2012
Arijit Basu says:
Football is a game of speed and skill, a good footballer is always skillful at his early age or later days. but the young legs are always helpful to the game planning of the team, at the same young guys are full of energy and they always try to proof themselves so they always try to give more than 100% in the field.
Now a days all the club teams of the world depend on their academy boys because these lads are perfectly grow up according to club motto, so when they start to play for their clubs, then they know exactly that what their club wants, and when these guys are on the field together for their senior team, then the team spirit and chemistry of the team formed double.
13 Jul 2012
rahul dasgupta says:
npe
13 Jul 2012
AGAINST
3 Opinions
& 2 Votes
mrl says:
I am agree with u @debangan Basu
16 Jul 2012
Soumik Chakraborty says:
juniors r signs of future bt they mst be mre maturd 2 ### 2 the senior team
13 Jul 2012
debangan basu says:
We've had reasonable success in this department. These are good signs that the club needs to build on. Academy players should be given international exposure to acclimatize them with the challenges that lie ahead
12 Jul 2012
Suggestions
Drop in your suggestion for the next debate. Click here
Archives
Quality international recruits will help Indian football grow.
Young players from the academy storming into the senior squad are positives signs for McDowell Mohun Bagan.
The team for the upcoming season is a good mix of youth and experience.
Are you happy with the team's performance in the warm up matches played thus far?
For clubs to field a full strength squad, should league fixtures be rescheduled when dates clash with international matches?
Should the Mariners play both Tolgay and Odafa in the starting XI for the Federation Cup?
Should Nabi be played at left-back instead of the midfield where he played in the Federation Cup?
Should the Indian strikers in the team be presented with more playing opportunity?
Is playing Aiborlang Khongjee as stopper a smart move by the coaching staff?
Should we get international referees to officiate important matches?
In Odafa's absence, is Nabi the best option we have as Tolgay's strike partner?
Now that Odafa & Tolgay are back in goal scoring form, will the team be a more formidable unit?
After the brilliant performance in the Calcutta Football League and a mere miss out in the IFA Shield, do you think the Mariners should give new players a chance for the I-League or continue with the team that is already playing?
"With Nabi, Tolgay, Maithani & Sabeeth in peak form, do you think the Mariners need to keep experimenting with their line-up or stick with the same?"
"The team is playing well, but conceding goals, soon after they get the lead. What do you think should be the solution to this?"
With Odafa being the highest goal scorer in the team, are we becoming too dependent on Odafa to score for us?
